Friday, August 3, 2007

The Queen of Air and Darkness

The second book in The Once and Future King, The Queen Of Air and Darkness, sets a different tone than the happy childhood story of Arthur in the first book The Sword in the Stone. The second book starts the hardships and tragedy that follow Arthur through his life while he tries to set up just ideals and better England.

In the beginning we see the Orkney boys Gawaine, Gaheris, Agravaine, and Gareth, and their mother Morgause, and the disturbing life they lead. Morgause is obsessed with herself and her sick beauty, paying little heed to her children's upbringing, showing them cruelty, and then random moments of affection to make herself feel perfect. The boys struggle with their lives and the confusion put forth by the mother they love. All show deep scars to their character do to their mother's poor parenting.

While fighting some of his Gaelic aggressors, Arthur has many discussions with Merlyn and Kay about might and right, and how might should be used. Merlyn states his opinions but forces Arthur to come to his own conclusions. Arthur finally puts down his opponents, and begins to start forming his ideals, his moral code of chivalry and decides he should have knights at a round table to avoid quarreling among the knights about rank.

In the end unknowing that Morgause is his half sister Arthur is seduced by her natural charm and a charm she wore around her neck, to sleep with her, and nine months later she gives birth to Mordred.

T.H. White is a perfectly wonderful writer. He weaves controversial subjects like war, and how it should be used into into his story thoughtfully and touchingly. His own opinions are obvious but there is room for discussion. Merlyn does not believe in fighting unless in self defence, and when Kay states that he thinks that if you had a valiant ideal but, people are to stupid to convert to it that you could use aggression for their own good, to make them understand it was for the best, Merlyn gets angry and makes reference to World War II and Hitler.

The Orkney boys are a tragic example of the effect that your lifestyle, surroundings and influences can have. Each of the boys loves his mother but all suffer because of her influence on them. they are never sure what is right or wrong, because their mother doesn't say, she will punish or ignore on a whim. They try to please her by catching the unicorn that she wanted, and at first she fails to even notice what they had done, and when she finally does notice, she has them beaten. Her flaunting of her sexuality and appeal ruins her son Agravaine, because he becomes confused and loves his mother in a way that he shouldn't.

In all the book is becoming more deep and the tragedy of it is starting to come out. Arthur has realized the basics of his ideals and plans to better England, but he still has the struggle to try to have them realized and followed ahead of him, and he will have to do it with only the help of Merlyns teachings sense Merlyn is soon to leave.

2 comments:

Miss Lind said...

This book is very different from the first one! I'm glad you noticed the references to WW II. How do you feel about the Orkney brothers? Are they unlikeable or do you feel sorry for them? Any thoughts about the whole Questing Beast episode?

Emily T. said...

I don't dislike the Orkney brothers exactly, I more feel bad for them and pitty them. It is hard to hate them, when most of the reason why they act in the brutal, confused, and sick ways they do, is because of their poor parentage and ignorance. At the same time, you can't blame every defect of your personality and wrong thing you do on the mistakes of someone else and be wiped free of any personal blame. But because in this book the children are still young it is just mostly sorrow and pitty that I feel for them.
I loved the questing beast pieces. They were a much needed comic relief, and interesting. I have always liked that the knights were so bumbling and distracted by their own ideas they payed little heed to Morgouse trying to seduce them. And I liked how even though at times those three knights seemed like their intelligence wasn't always all there, that they really were good people and caring friends, to go to such strange langths to cheer eachother. The fact that the real questing beast fell in love with the fake, seems a little bitter sweet, but still laughable.

Contributors